In-depth Guide: TOP 10 Best Dog Training Collar in 2019

In-depth Guide: TOP 10 Best Dog Training Collar in 2019

Hey there, If you are confused as to which dog training collar to buy, we’ve got you covered. 

I know the importance and need of getting a dog training collar for a dog that proves to be stubborn in obeying commands.

In this post, you will get to know about the best dog training collar you could use for your dog.

All the products listed in this guide have been well-researched and I have even used one myself. The products can be purchased from Amazon. 

Hey, don’t be scared, there are affordable, well, most of them.

If your dog won’t obey commands or is a really bad boy or girl, you can put an end to that with special dog training collars. From vibrating training collars, dog walking collars to hunting dog training collars, we have got all covered.

Put your seatbelts on, we are about to take off!

Our Top Pick

Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar

I’ve decided to go with this dog training collar as my overall best for some basic reasons which are;

Best waterproof dog training collarKey Features

  • Its water resistivity is top-notch.
  • It holds a charge well.
  • It is quite convenient to carry.

A Glance

No matter how distracted your dog is, this device has the power to get his or her attention. Although this might not be suitable for small dogs, it can be used on medium to large dogs. You don’t need to worry about your dog getting hurt, the Dogtra 1900S is said to be very comfortable. 

If you have a duck hunting dog or a Lab this is an amazing pick. Another feature I love about this dog training collar is its water resistivity, not only the receiver is water-resistant, even the remote can resist damage caused by water. That’s amazing!

People with dogs less than 4 months old are not allowed to use this device. Please, don’t put this on your puppy’s neck. 

So, let’s say you purchased this and you are expecting the delivery man, here’s what you’ll find in the box; – A Dogtra 1900S Collar Transmitter, Dogtra 1900S Collar Receiver, PetsTEK Training Clicker, Battery Charger, Test Light, Splitter Cable, Owner’s Manual.

Top Best Dog Training Collar Review

1. Pawious Dog Training Collar – Best remote dog training collar

Best remote dog training collarThe Pawious dog training collar is rechargeable and waterproof and has proven to be safe. This is an ideal remote dog training collar. Will I pick this over other remote collars? Yes, I will. Are there other amazing remote dog training collars? Sure! 

This collar is also comfortable if you use it well on your dog. If you have a small, medium or large dog, the Pawious Dog Training collar works wonders. This system gives you the ability to control your canine bud within a range of up to 1000-1600 feet. With the beep, shock and vibrate feature, teaching obedience to your dog is way easier using the Pawious Dog Training Collar.

  • It has high quality compared to other remote dog training collars.
  • It is waterproof.
  • If your remote gets bad, you can’t replace it, you need to buy the complete set.
  • No turn off button for the remote.

2. PATPET-US Shock Collar for Dogs – Best dog training collar under 100

Best dog training collar under 100Most dog collars you’d find out there always fall below the 100 dollar range. If you are looking for an amazing one that is quite cheap but yet very effective then you should consider the Shock Collar for Dogs from PATPET-US. With over 3000ft remote range this collar won’t be a bug to you range wise. Would you want your dog collar to hurt your dog by shocking him or her accidentally? This collar has an anti-jamming technology that supports a stable signal for multiple training environments. 

The Shock Collar for dogs – IPX7 is said to work great for German Shepherds. If your dog is very aggressive or below 6 months old you shouldn’t buy this collar.

  • Long-lasting battery.
  • Works from a far range.
  • Not suitable for aggressive dogs.
  • It is not suitable for dogs below 6 months.

3. Coastal Walk’n Train Head Halter – Best dog walking training collar

Best dog walking training collarIf you want to stop your dog from controlling you while both of you are taking a walk, you could consider training him or her. I have seen lots of dog owners struggling with their dogs while walking, the situation is most times annoying. But there’s a way out of this unfortunate situation. The Coastal Walk’n Train Head halter is the perfect header that will teach or train your dog how to walk right. 

This walking training collar might not be suitable for all dog breeds though. If you have a strong dog and you are skeptical about getting this collar, you shouldn’t be. It serves as a great walking training collar.

  • The collar is lightweight.
  • It works well with strong dogs.
  • A determined dog might still pull.
  • It might not be so durable.

4. Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar – Best waterproof dog training collar

Best waterproof dog training collarHere is my favourite remote training collar. If you’re looking for quality and durability, this is a great pick. Listen guys, there are lots of waterproof dog training collars out there, but for me, this particular collar is quite exceptional. It is fully waterproof. Designed to fit dogs who have neck sizes between 6 – 26 inches, this collar promises to be comfortable on your dog’s neck.

Some features of this remote training collar include; an LCD screen showing the current level of stimulation, Momentary Nick, Constant Stimulation, and Non-Stimulating High Power Pager Vibration training modes.

It’s undeniably one of the best waterproof collars you can find out there. 

  • It has a 3/4 mile range.
  • It is convenient to carry.
  • It works great for almost all kinds of dogs.
  • Not suitable for puppies.
  • It is relatively expensive.

5. Dog Training Collar – Best vibrating dog training collar

Best vibrating dog training collarIf you meet me when I am walking my dog and ask me, “Hey, which is the best vibrating dog training collar?” I would most definitely recommend this one to you. Why would I recommend this vibrating dog collar? My friend Matt uses this for his dog and from what he tells me, I think his experience with this collar has been amazingly outstanding so far.

It has two other modes too, the shock and beep mode. Using this device to train your furry best friend will surely yield positive results. This vibrating training collar also has a remote that you can use. 

  • The battery life is amazing and can last for a long period.
  • It is very easy to use.
  • Not suitable for small dogs.
  • The remote might be a bit large for some people.

6. SportDOG Brand SportHunter – Best electronic dog training collar

Best electronic dog training collarThe job of an electronic training collar is to apply a light electric current to a dog’s neck, this is done to give them a signal. You don’t need to worry about your furry friend being zapped to death, the electric current applied is light and won’t hurt your dog. But that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t be careful. 

The SportDOG training collar has different variations to choose from based on your needs, there’s the ½ mile radius, ¾ mile and even 1 mile each varies in price, the longer the range the higher the price. Unlike other dog training collars, this one has a low battery indicator that tells you when it is time to charge the device.

In summary, the SportDOG Brand SportHunter is an amazing electronic dog training collar that you could use to teach your dogs basic tricks. 

  • It provides a long-range capability of up to 1/2 miles.
  • It has a 2-hour quick charge feature.
  • Battery life might be short.
  • It might not last so long (rather short life span).

7. iThrough Shock Collar – Best small dog training collar

Best small dog training collarThe little ones are not left out too, you can’t use a collar meant for a big dog on a small dog. You need to consider the fact that a large/heavy training collar might hurt your dog. Equipped with just levels 1-5, the iThrough shock collar is the best pick for small dogs. It has an adjustable strap making it possible to fit the training collar on almost any small dog. 

You will love the design of this training collar trust me, and the battery too is something worthy of note. The through shock collar is powered with a built-in 300mAh battery for both receiver and remote. As for range, this device can work within a 300-meter range. 

With this small dog training collar, you can put an end to annoying behavior like barking, chasing, licking, and other behaviors you don’t like with ease.

  • It has good battery life.
  • It is suitable for small dogs.
  • The beeping isn’t too loud.
  • Vibration mode might be weak even on high settings.

8. SportDog – SD-425 – Best hunting dog training collar

Best hunting dog training collarThe Camo WetlandHunter is yet another amazing dog training collar, you can buy this collar if you have a hunting dog. This collar is great for hunting dogs. While training your dog to become the perfect duck or bird hunter, you could make the training process easier for you by using a training collar. 

The SportDog wetlandHunter is not suitable for small dogs. It is waterproof and submersible to 25 feet. Amazing! Doesn’t matter if your Lab dog is aggressive or stubborn, this collar can solve the issue in no time. I think you should totally get this for your hunting dog.

  • It withstands water.
  • Great for medium and large dogs.
  • Both items are rechargeable.
  • It is more expensive than regular electric collars.
  • It might not be suitable for small dogs.

9. WOLFWILL 100% – Best training collar for deaf dog

Best training collar for deaf dogIf you have a deaf dog, training him or her is very easy with the help of a special training collar. The WOLFWILL training collar is ideal for deaf dogs. A deaf dog won’t understand when you say sit, stand, stop or leave it. It is impossible to train a deaf dog vocally. 

A training collar is useful for training a deaf dog. The vibrations from the collar will be suitable enough to train your dog. The goal is for the dog to associate the vibrations produced by the collar with specific commands you wish to teach him or her.

  • It is rechargeable.
  • It works great for deaf dogs.
  • The tone is not too loud.
  • It might be big for small size dogs.

10. Electric Dog Fence + Remote Trainer – Best dog training collar for the money

Best dog training collar for the moneyDo you have 2-5 dogs and bucks to spend? Here’s an expensive collar that will make you spend cash. This collar is ideal if you have a large yard. This electric dog fence + Remote trainer system is both a remote trainer and an electric dog fence. 

I love this device, you can actually train 3 dogs at a time, that’s amazing! If you have a dog that loves crossing the road, this device can also save your dog’s life whenever he or she leaves the zone.

  • Suitable for medium to large dogs.
  • Amazing containment system.
  • Not suitable for small dogs.
  • Battery life on the collar might not last long enough.

Complete Guide: Before Buying Training Collar for Your Dogs

How To Choose The Perfect Dog Training Collar

Before selecting the perfect dog training collar for your dog you need to consider some factors, we don’t want you to feel bad or regret. So, here’s a guide for people that are getting a dog training collar for the first time.

Collar Size

Very important, you need to consider the collar size, you don’t want to purchase a large collar for your small dog, you need to double and triple check the size and make sure it works for your dog. This can be done by measuring your dog’s neck.

Below is a video on how you can measure the neck size of your furry baby.


There are dog training collars that use can use to control your dog from ½ mile and even up to ¾ miles. If you have a hunting dog ¾ miles seems like a great pick.


Due to the vibration, beep or shock from the collar, not all dogs will love their new training collar. But that shouldn’t stop you from choosing a collar that will be comfortable on your dog’s neck. If your dog doesn’t like normal nylon collars then he or she wouldn’t like the training nylon ones either, you can go for leather ones. Give your dog the comfort he or she needs.

How To Use A Dog Training Collar

So, you just got a training collar for your dog. Safety is of extreme importance when using an electric dog training collar. When training collars are used incorrectly they will be ineffective on your dog and might even scare your dog. Here’s are short tips on how you can use your training collar and with little or no effects on your fur baby. 

  • Read the instructional manual thoroughly before using the training collar on your dog.
  • Get familiar with the functions of the training collar before using it on your dog.
  • Make sure the training collar fits the dog’s neck properly (not too tight).
  • Know the right timing before triggering the collar.

Advantages Of Using Dog Training Collars

Best Dog Training Collar

As a first-timer getting a dog training collar, you may want to know some advantages of using these training collars on your dog. Here goes;

Dog Training Collars Help When Vocal Commands Fail: 

I have met a couple of dogs who just won’t obey your commands. I call them the “very stubborn ones” These buddies can be a real pain. If your dog doesn’t obey your verbal commands you can employ the dog training collar method. It works like magic even if you have a deaf dog.

They Minimize Aggression:

If your dog isn’t used to seeing lots of faces, there’s a tendency that it will get pumped up and start barking excessively when it meets new people. Also, if you have a rescue dog that has been abused by its previous owner, that might be the major cause of its aggression. Dogs that are aggressive in behavior can pose a threat. I know a couple of folks who have tried to calm down their aggressive dog with gentle training methods with little or no success rate. 

With a dog training collar, aggressive behavior can be minimized significantly. It can also work when you are away. Although other dog calming methods might work, the dog training collar remains an effective way to minimize aggression.

It Isn’t Too Expensive:

Basic dog training collars don’t cost much unless you are going for a training collar set for 2-5 dogs. They are collars that are quite cheap and can get the training task done. It’s a win-win situation, your dog gets a comfortable collar and you get to spend less. Cool right?

Punishment Doesn’t Come From You:

Uhm, yeah, most times you would have to push that vibrate, shock or beep button and that means it’s coming from you but your dog might not understand that, unless he or she has previously evolved into a super Einstein mutated dog. 

But seriously, punishment doesn’t come from you, if your dog associates the punishment with you, it can mess up the dog-owner bond and thus get it the way of future training.

It Can Be Used To Train More Dogs At a Time:

If you are looking at training two, three or even five dogs at a time, training collars are the perfect thing. 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Are training collars bad for dogs?
Although training collars have risks, it remains a fast and effective method of getting your dog to do your bidding. Most training collars come with 3 modes, the shock, vibration, and sound mode.

The only mode that seems to pose a threat is the shock mode, but not to worry, the shock mode is designed in such a way that it doesn’t hurt your dog, the shock mode is designed to get your dog’s immediate attention. It works best when you have a dog that barks regularly. 

However you need to be careful, a piece of equipment like this tends to malfunction.

What is the best remote dog training collar?
There are lots of remote dog training collars worth your money, but I think the Dogtra 1900S is an amazing work of art. Although not cheap, it has amazing features that you are going to love.

From its water resistivity to a shocking 3/4 mile range usage with the remote. It also has a continuous stimulation mode in case your dog is not paying attention to the manual signals you are sending. For your money, you also get a PetsTek training clicker.

Should dog wear collar all the time?
There are lots of things that can go wrong when a collar is always on your dog’s neck. Normal collars can stay on your dog’s neck for a while, but you should take it off for some time for his or her skin to air out. This is not the case however for a training collar, If you are using a training collar on your dog you should take it off when not needed.

Most dog training collars manuals say that the maximum time you should allow a training collar to be on your dog’s neck is 10-12 hours. To avoid skin irritation of any kind, your dog should not wear a training collar for too long.


If you have a stubborn dog that just won’t listen to you, using a training collar for your canine best friend could be the best thing you could do that will get him or her to behave right. And no! You are not a bad dog owner for using a training collar on your dog. Just a little vibration or shock won’t kill your dog. 

Look on the bright side, after your dog must have mastered the skill or trick you are teaching him or her, you can always take the collar off and never have to use it again. 

When choosing a collar you need to consider a whole of factors before buying, like the size, for example, you wouldn’t want to buy a collar that won’t fit your dog’s neck now, would you? Your furry angel deserves the best dog training collar and you totally should give him or her the best!

In-depth Guide: TOP 10 Best Dog Training Collar in 2019

Written by Dr. Alex Boyum

Editor's Rating:

Leave a Comment